Why We Oppose Flock
Privacy. Local Control. Civil Rights.
The Case Against Mass Surveillance
Flock Safety cameras represent a fundamental shift toward mass surveillance in Woodbury. Woodbury police credit the cameras with real arrests. Our concern is the system's design: it records every passing car, not just suspects, and every protection depends on settings the department can change without a vote.
1. Privacy & Digital Rights
Flock cameras use Automatic License Plate Recognition (ALPR) to photograph and log every vehicle that passes, including plate, time, and location. Woodbury's 20 cameras ring the retail areas almost every resident drives through each week.
- Everyone, not suspects: No reasonable suspicion is needed. Woodbury's own Policy 425.4(b) says "reasonable suspicion or probable cause is not necessary before using an ALPR."
- Retention is a setting, not a law: Woodbury now keeps data for 7 days. That was 30 until recently, and the written policy still allows 60. The same office can change it back.
- Vendor security: The images sit on Flock's servers. 404 Media reported Flock cameras left streaming openly on the internet, and the city policy never mentions Flock or cloud security.
- Function creep: What Flock says is used for "public safety" today can be repurposed for surveillance tomorrow.
Driving to the store shouldn't put you in a police database by default.
2. Immigration Enforcement: Promises vs. Policy
Nationally, reporters found local police running Flock searches for immigration enforcement in 2025, and Flock's network let agencies search each other's cameras. Woodbury's department says it does not allow that here. Our point is that the promise isn't binding.
- What the department says: "We do not allow any searches for immigration or civil purposes" (Woodbury PD ALPR video, 2026).
- What the written policy says: Policy 425 never mentions immigration. It lists "homeland security" as an approved use and allows access for "civil or administrative action."
- Three years of sharing: Woodbury shared data with approved outside agencies from 2022 until summer 2026. We don't yet know which agencies or what they searched.
- Other cities wrote it down: Fridley disabled immigration searches and cut out-of-state access.
If the department means it, put it in a city ordinance.
3. Local Control & Democratic Oversight
Flock decisions should be made by residents and their elected representatives—not corporate surveillance companies.
- Corporate control: Flock Safety profits from surveillance. The company designs the system, controls the data, and sets the rules. Woodbury residents have minimal say.
- Transparency gaps: Woodbury has a policy, a transparency portal, and a state audit that found it compliant. But the contract, the total number of plates scanned, and the list of agencies that received our data aren't published.
- Results without the denominator: The department reports 64 people arrested or cited from January to August 2026. It hasn't said how many cars were scanned to get there, though its policy requires a public log of exactly that.
- Irreversibility: Once deployed, these systems are difficult to remove. Woodbury is locking in permanent surveillance infrastructure.
Technology deployment decisions belong to the public, not corporations. Woodbury residents have the right to know and decide what surveillance infrastructure operates in our city.
4. Better Alternatives Exist
Woodbury doesn't need mass surveillance to improve public safety.
- Community policing: Trust-based relationships between police and residents are proven to improve safety.
- Targeted investigation: Police can deploy cameras where needed for specific investigations, with warrants and accountability.
- Pedestrian & traffic safety: Many cities improve safety through street design, lighting, and intersection improvements—not surveillance.
- Prevention & intervention: Resources spent on surveillance could go to youth programs, mental health services, and community investment.
5. Precedent: Minnesota Cities Are Pulling Back
- St. Paul: The council unanimously called for removal, and city leaders announced the Flock cameras would come down (August 2026).
- Columbia Heights: Ended all Flock contracts and removed 12 cameras (June 2026).
- Crystal: Removed six readers. The chief said "the community concern outweighed their usefulness" (September 2026).
- Duluth: Let its contract lapse (September 2026).
- North Branch: Paused its contract (August 2026).
What worked: Residents showing up, asking specific questions, and requesting public records.
📍 The Path Forward
Woodbury has a choice: embrace mass surveillance or defend privacy and local control.
We choose privacy. We choose local control. We choose democracy.