⏰ 2027: The Settlement Gap
The 3M settlement is ending sooner than planned. A mediation happening right now decides who pays to run Woodbury's treatment plant for as long as PFAS stays in our water.
📊 Where the Money Stands
From the state's own October 2026 report to the Legislature (MPCA and DNR, the settlement's Co-Trustees):
📅 How We Got Here
Consent Order: A separate legal agreement between the State and 3M. It requires 3M to fund treatment for drinking water wells that exceed state health guidance.
$850M settlement: About $720M remained after legal and other expenses. Investment earnings have added more than $100M since, bringing the total to roughly $820M.
Standards tighten: In January, MDH lowered its health-based values for PFOS (2.3 ppt) and PFOA (0.0079 ppt). In April, EPA set enforceable limits of 4 ppt. More wells exceeded the limits than the 2021 plan expected, and costs climbed.
Woodbury's plant: Construction of a roughly $300–330M treatment plant and pipelines. The city says about 93% is covered by the settlement, and its own share is under $20M.
Mediation: "The Co-Trustees are in mediation with 3M Company regarding the eventual transition from 3M Settlement funds to the 2007 Consent Order."
The fund ends: The state tracks the date the fund will be fully committed but doesn't publish it. After that, the 2007 Consent Order is supposed to take over.
❓ The Real Question
The promise: Woodbury's assistant public works director told FOX 9 in 2025, "It was thought that operation and maintenance costs would be covered for 20 years," and added, "there's some uncertainty on that."
The dispute: 3M is challenging whether some projects are "reasonable and necessary" under the 2007 Consent Order, and has asked for an independent review of how settlement money is spent.
What's at stake: Building the plant is paid for. Running it is not settled. Carbon media, chemicals, operators and testing are needed every year. PFAS doesn't break down.
💰 What It Could Cost You
If 3M stops paying to operate the plant, here is our estimate of the added cost per household. It covers only the water portion of the bill, not sewer or stormwater.
| Conservative | High | |
|---|---|---|
| Annual plant operating cost | $3M | $6M |
| Share paid by homes | 70% | 100% |
| Added cost per household (2028) | +$18/quarter | +$51/quarter |
| Increase on the water portion of the bill | +30% | +85% |
| Same scenario in 2035 (3% inflation) | +39% | +111% |
How we got these numbers:
- The city says the plant will cost "several millions of dollars annually" to run but hasn't published a figure. $3M and $6M are our low and high readings of that.
- We spread the cost over 29,312 households (U.S. Census, 2020–2024).
- Today's bill uses the city's 2026 residential rates ($10.20 per quarter plus $2.50 per 1,000 gallons) at 20,000 gallons per quarter, which comes to about $60 a quarter for water.
- If the Consent Order covers operations in full, the added cost to residents is close to $0.
🔮 How This Could Play Out
Nobody outside the mediation knows the odds. These are the possible outcomes.
3M covers operations
The Consent Order transition funds treatment, including operations, for as long as wells exceed health limits. Residents see little or no PFAS-related rate increase.
Partial coverage
The mediation produces a compromise. 3M pays some operating costs, and cities and ratepayers cover the rest.
3M wins the disputes
Costs ruled not "reasonable and necessary" fall to the city. In Cottage Grove, Ryan Burfeind told the Star Tribune "the only option would be to increase water rates."
State or federal help
Woodbury and its legislators have sought a state sales-tax exemption on construction materials. That lowers building costs, not ongoing operations.
✋ What We're Asking the City
- Publish the operating budget: the plant's expected annual operating cost, with rate projections for 2028, 2030 and 2035 if 3M stops paying.
- Report on the mediation: who represents Woodbury, and whether we are demanding that operations be covered for as long as PFAS is in our water.
- A public hearing on PFAS rate increases: no PFAS-related rate increase without its own hearing.
- Rate assistance: help for families who can't absorb an increase.
- Work with other cities: coordinate with Cottage Grove, Hastings, Lake Elmo, Oakdale and the other East Metro communities.
🎯 The Bottom Line
3M paid for the filter. The question is who pays to change it.
The settlement built Woodbury's plant. Whether it keeps running without landing on our water bills depends on a mediation residents can't see. The city should tell us where it stands before the bill arrives.
📚 Sources
- MPCA & DNR, 3M Settlement annual report and spending plan for fiscal year 2027 (lrc-pfc-2sy26), October 2026.
- City of Woodbury, Addressing PFAS in Drinking Water.
- City of Woodbury, Residential Utility Rates (2026).
- FOX 9, 3M is paying to clean up PFAS. But for how much longer? (July 2025).
- Star Tribune, 3M settlement over PFAS in MN drinking water could run out by 2027 (March 2025).
- U.S. Census Bureau, QuickFacts: Woodbury city, Minnesota.
What's Next?
See which of Woodbury's 20 wells are affected, and how each one is treated.
Next: The 20 Wells →